Page 1 of 1

Disconnect after PASV response

Posted: 2022-01-12 02:05
by Yaj3021
Windows 10, static IP, on LAN side of router/NAT 192.168.3.10
Custom hardware design, static IP, on LAN size of router/NAT 192.168.3.201

Immediate disconnect of Filezilla client by Windows 10 upon receipt of PASV response. Internet search shows it's a common problem, but haven't seen a workaround or why.

Famous last words, used to work, just fired up an old XP box on the same LAN with a very earlier version of Filezilla 3.0.7.1 - still works.

I'm trying to understand the logic of requiring an external IP address of the router/NAT in the PASV response. If I were to somehow implement this in the custom hardware, it seems that the router/NAT would need a port forwarding rule?

Any input or pointers? The control port access works fine using the LAN static IP addresses, just not the PASV (192.168.3.201,0,20).

Is there a registry or policy setting to disable this 'feature' ?

Thank you !

Re: Disconnect after PASV response

Posted: 2022-01-12 09:44
by botg
Please post a complete log of this happening.

Re: Disconnect after PASV response

Posted: 2022-01-12 18:44
by Yaj3021
2 logfiles and screen capture attached.

Re: Disconnect after PASV response

Posted: 2022-01-13 09:26
by botg
The reply to the PASV command never makes it to the client. Instead the client gets handed a socket error by the TCP stack.

Some badly behaving firewall?