another 425 Can't open data connection

[Gundersau]

Hey Guys,

i have the common 425 can't open data connection problem.
Background:
Server -->Firewall-->Router:fix iP -->Internet-->Router-->Firewall --> Client.

On ther Server side:
Filezilla Server: Use passive Mode, Custom portrange 5000-5100, use fix IP: blah blah

Firewall: Windows Firewall + zonealarm deactivated (not unistalled, though)

Router (Netgear v614): Ports 20/21, 5000-5100 forwarded to Servers Lan IP

Client Side:
Filezilla: Use passive Mode

Firewall: Windows Firewall + Zonealarm deactivated (also not uninstalled)

Router: Nothing forwarded


This is what i get:

Antwort: 220-FileZilla Server version 0.9.23 beta
Antwort: 220 Welcome to xxxxxxxxxxx FTP-Server
Befehl: USER xxxxxxxx
Antwort: 331 Password required for xxxxxxx
Befehl: PASS ************
Antwort: 230 Logged on
Befehl: FEAT
Antwort: 211-Features:
Antwort: MDTM
Antwort: REST STREAM
Antwort: SIZE
Antwort: MLST type*;size*;modify*;
Antwort: MLSD
Antwort: UTF8
Antwort: CLNT
Antwort: MFMT
Antwort: 211 End
Befehl: CLNT FileZilla
Antwort: 200 Don't care
Befehl: OPTS UTF8 ON
Antwort: 200 UTF8 mode enabled
Befehl: SYST
Antwort: 215 UNIX emulated by FileZilla
Status: Verbindung hergestellt
Status: Verzeichnisinhalt wird abgeholt...
Befehl: PWD
Antwort: 257 "/" is current directory.
Befehl: TYPE A
Antwort: 200 Type set to A
Befehl: PASV
Antwort: 227 Entering Passive Mode (xxx,xxx,xxx,130,113)
Befehl: LIST
Antwort: 425 Can't open data connection.
Fehler: Dateiliste konnte nicht empfangen werden
Befehl: PWD
Antwort: 257 "/" is current directory.
Befehl: TYPE A
Antwort: 200 Type set to A

Funny thing though, active mode from the client and via web2ftp-service works

[botg]

http://filezilla-project.org/wiki/index ... figuration

[Gundersau]

Thx botg,

already worked that one through, though.
I tried to deinstall Zonealarm on both sides, didn't help.
Without the firewall, the client should be fine in passive mode...
And the server is configured by the book. So is it's router...

And still, the funny thing is: the client side router is NOT configured for port forwarding or anything... but active mode works just perfectly

[botg]

And still, the funny thing is: the client side router is NOT configured for port forwarding or anything... but active mode works just perfectly

Ah, the joy of ninja routers. They just assume the protocol change data in it and transparently open ports. That obviously fails if using encryption or if using some protocol extensions. Consumer hardware... *sigh*

[Gundersau]

Ah ok, do have any suggestions for a better router?(mine is a netgear rp614 btw.)

[botg]

Everything that can load from a Linux Live-CD is far far better

[Gundersau]

New router did the trick. Thx